RSS Feed

Tools for the angry preschooler

Let me preface this post by emphatically declaring that I’ve messed up more times than I can count in my parenting. I’d rather not blog about those. Positive discipline teaches us that mistakes help children grow and learn. It works for mommies, too.

My first step was to figure out Norah’s mistaken goal. Positive discipline (PD) says that children have four “mistaken goals” which drive most misbehavior. The easiest way to figure out which mistaken goal the child is using? Look at how the parent feels or reacts when the child misbehaves. When Norah gets angry, I feel defeated. Her mistaken goal is POWER. In order to belong, she tries to be the boss. Her mistaken belief is “I belong only when I’m boss, in control, or proving no one can boss me. You can’t make me.”

A common phrase I’ve heard this year: You’re not the boss of me.

Also, “You’re not the boss of my toys.” “You’re not the boss of my brain.” “You’re not the boss of my food.” You’re not the boss of my behavior.” “You’re not the boss of my [fill in the blank].”

Interestingly, she’s taught me so much with this phrasing. How much do we control another person? Even our children. I don’t control her choices. I control the consequences and that is my responsibility. But she gets to make a choice to misbehave. Such an important thing to learn.

My PD handbook has some amazing ideas for redirecting her power in positive ways. Mostly, she needs to contribute to the family, have limited choices, routines, and engage in deciding consequences.

I needed to get a handle on my own anger. Anger is not my typical response.

Until Norah turned 5.

It is as if I had a tiny spark inside and she pours a gallon of gasoline on it. A few things that have helped: eating protein every few hours, using mommy time-outs, and giving Norah permission to call me on it. She tells me if I’m “flipping my lid.” I also apologized for my past angry reactions. I cried when she told me that my words were all fuzzy to her ears when I yelled.

I helped Norah make an Anger Wheel of Choice. When she flipped her lid, we could use the wheel to decide on a way to diffuse her emotion. Her choices: run a race, use playdough, read a book, snuggle, draw, or eat candy (it is her wheel…her choice!). We kept the wheel in a bag with all the necessary tools to implement. If we went to the park or a playdate, the bag went with us. Honestly, we only used the wheel maybe 6 times. A few times we should have used it, but I was too angry and just packed everyone up and went home. Learn from mistakes, learn from mistakes. She doesn’t have those awful tantrums anymore (knock on wood) so we’ve unpacked the bag.

Another tool that we’ve lately used is the yellow bracelet. Super creative title, I realize. It was one of those spur of the moment tools. I almost always have a ponytail holder on my wrist for Cedar’s unruly hair. One day, it was yellow. Norah’s emotions were intensifying and I took the yellow ponytail holder off my wrist and put it on hers. I explained that just like yellow traffic lights tell us to slow down, when I put the yellow bracelet on her wrist, she needs to slow down her big feelings. Breathe deeply, find a quiet place, whatever it takes. The strangest part was that when she calmed down, she returned the bracelet to my wrist without a word. Her choice to return to “green light” mode. I love this tool because Norah is sensitive to public shame (aren’t we all?) and I can use this tool without a word. It is a code language for us. And she always returns it to me (sometimes long after I’ve forgotten about the whole ordeal).

The glitter ball was another spontaneous tool though I’ve since seen a similar tool on pinterest. The girls have these bouncy balls filled with glitter. We only use this one at home. I hand her the glitter ball and ask her to settle her big feelings until the ball is clear. Sometimes she gives it a few new shakes.

Positive time-out. We once used a comfort corner and I probably need to make one for Cedar. For Norah, I ask her to go to her room until she can calm herself. Usually this one is reserved for times that her behavior hurts someone else either physically or verbally. She is not forced to remain. She knows she can rejoin the family at any point. Her crazy self-discipline skills come in handy here. She really does pull it together before coming out.

Mommy time-out. Norah knows that I cannot allow her to hurt my heart or my ears. When this happens, mommy must step away. I have explained to her that I will never leave her in an unsafe place, I will always come back, and she continues to have access to me. If I must withdraw in a public place (say, the zoo), I will simply walk a few steps away while continuing to supervise her. If we are at home, I may go into my room and shut the door.

Of course, the best tool is connection. To remind her that she automatically belongs without feeling the need to use a mistaken goal.

P.S. While admittedly, I do not have all the answers, I will soon be offering a Positive Discipline for Toddlers workshop in Greenville. We’ll learn from each other’s mistakes, yes?

14 responses »

  1. Sooo helpful. I love the yellow bracelet idea, and the wheel/bag of choices that you take on playdates. Jordan and I would love to come to the workshop when you do it!

  2. Oh yes, please offer a class! We’re all still learning, and I most of all. I need to be preparing for Edie hitting these stages early and often – my brain must be retrained.

    And thanks for sharing so honestly. These are things I can use even now with C & J & of course me.

  3. I like these ideas. I have been yelling so much lately. I put myself in time-out yesterday. I felt better. Sigh.

  4. Julie, you rock. Truly. I’ve had struggles with boy #2 for ever, and still do. New struggles with boy #1 (why, oh why, do the pre-teen hormones start between age 8-9?!? no fair!) and now boy #3 is picking up on things boy #2 has modeled… I need to try some of these new things you’ve taught in this post. Thanks. 🙂

  5. Will you be doing a PD for preteen/young teens? Because I SOOOOOOO need it.

    Maybe email me some hints and tricks? I will love you forever.

  6. Julie Storm Smith

    I would love to come to a workshop when you offer one! I have been reading the positive parenting site, but more tools are always helpful!

  7. Pingback: Positive Discipline Parent Interview – 10 Questions with Julie Byers | THINKitTHROUGHparenting

  8. Well done mama!!! I especially appreciate how clear you made each of the tools for readers, thank you.

  9. Holy Cow, this is a great post! Can we perhaps interview you for our radio show (really) We’re at

  10. Great ideas! Wish j had these 8 years ago. Unfortunately my now 13 yo ADHD ODD son still has a difficult time controlling his feelings/anger. With such low impulse control, sometimes the things that come out of his mouth when he’s gone off the deep end truly cut to the heart and leave scars. He always apologizes later but it still hurts. Any advice to help?

  11. Julie, My heart sings as I read how fabulous you are at applying Positive Discipline–mistakes and all. Keep sharing. You are an inspiration to every parent who is fortunate enough to find your blog. Warmly, Jane Nelsen


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: